Press Centre

Press Centre

What older people need is not choice, but companionship

24th June 2013

ResPublica Associate Alex Fox writes in the Guardian on our Putting People into Personalisation report

Government policies for older people’s care aim to offer them choice and control over their support. This choice-based approach reflects similar developments in support for working-age disabled adults, and has come to underpin many of our public services. But as we argue in a ResPublica paper, published on Wednesday, the choice to remain an active, valued and included member of the local community has become increasingly out of reach to many older people.

The approach also doesn’t offer what older people really want and need – other people. As the UK’s population ages dramatically, so does the number who are lonely, isolated and poorly housed.

Some argue that this demonstrates that older people don’t want choices, just more reliable traditional services. Another interpretation is that choice is only valuable where a range of good, safe options is available and at least one fits the chooser’s particular wishes. Older people know that good support enables them not only to be cared for as an individual, but also to keep in touch with old friends and make new ones. It ensures their needs are met and that they can feel useful to those around them.

There are ways of delivering services that do just that. Shared Lives (SL), the UK network for family-based, small-scale ways of supporting adults, is increasingly being adapted for older people. SL carers are matched with an adult who needs support and, where possible, has a shared interest. They then share family and community life. For younger adults this often means living with the SL carer as part of their family for a short or extended period. An older person with dementia more typically becomes a regular visitor at the SL carer’s house for day support or short breaks in a familiar homely setting.

Another scheme, Homeshare, links up isolated, older adults with carefully vetted young people. Again, they are matched for compatability, and share housing, helping to meet each other’s needs. Both schemes are funded by the charity, Shared Lives Plus, which receives most of its income from government grants, charitable trusts and membership fees.

The goal is for everyone to be able to contribute, as well as receive the support they need. It is a far cry from the image of older people sitting around the walls of a care home lounge or waiting alone for the next 15-minute slot of home support from their “chosen” agency.

But these alternatives are little known, victims of their own success in blending into their communities. Crucially, though, they are cheaper than traditional alternatives. The average saving of someone transferring from residential care to a SL scheme is about £13,000 a year. To bring them into the mainstream, councils need to match the energy they invest into creating ways to exercise choice with an effort to ensure that there is a genuine range of opportunities for older people to become active members of their communities, rather than passive consumers of services.

The Guardian Article

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Time limit is exhausted. Please reload CAPTCHA.

Food security, accessibility, and sustainability should be categorised as a publ...

Food security, accessibility, and sustainability should be categorised as a public good says new report by the Lifelong Education Institute   The Lifelong Education Institute’s latest report ‘Hungry to Learn: Lifelong Learning Pathways for the Agri-food Sector’ raises concerns over the neglected potential of the agri-food sector in the UK, and especially around the gap between its skills requirements and the available skills provision by agri-food education institutions....


A new report, Behaving to Learn, by the think tank ResPublica challenges the Government to be bold and drive a revolution in behaviour management across state schools to improve the outcomes for children and the lives of teachers....

New collection of essays by Conservative MPs offers fresh ideas for tackling pov...

PRESS RELEASE EMBARGOED | 24th MAY 2023 00:01 For Media Enquires please contact

Playing by The Rules | Press Release

PRESS RELEASE New independent regulator needed to protect English football clubs and give working-class fans a greater voice Ahead of the much-anticipated publication of the Government White Paper on the creation of a new independent regulator for English football (IREF), think-tank ResPublica warns that it must not be an ‘owners’ and directors’ charter’ and must ensure that the game’s fans are treated as highly-valued stakeholders and given a greater voice at both club and national level....

How smart solar at scale can power UK’s economic recovery

In its latest report, ‘Smart Solar at Scale: Meeting the UK’s net-zero emissions and clean growth targets’, ResPublica argues that the energy sector can play a central role in powering the UK’s economic recovery, post-Covid-19....

Press Release
  • Comments Off on ResPublica Report | Size doesn’t matter, small places must not be left behind in the devolution process.
ResPublica Report | Size doesn’t matter, small places must not be left behind...

The Government’s focus on metro-regions has meant that mid-sized cities, towns, districts, and counties have been locked-out of the devolution process....

Phillip Blond on LBC with Shelagh Fogarty

Listen to Shelagh Fogart from LBC, interviewing ResPublica’s Director, Phillip Blond, on the need to reform NHS Services....

Press Release
  • Comments Off on ResPublica Report | How to improve the Health and Wellbeing of the UK population
ResPublica Report | How to improve the Health and Wellbeing of the UK population

A new report launched today by the independent think tank ResPublica, set out how we can properly refigure our public health system in the light of its successes and failings in the Covid-19 epidemic....

Press Release
Election pledges will not meet the UK’s future skill needs

The next Government must unleash the potential of the UK’s workforce to compete in the 21st century economy.  ...