ResPublica, in partnership with the Jubilee Centre, sets out to reaffirm the value and purpose of our great professions in our latest report In Professions We Trust: Fostering virtuous practitioners in teaching, law and medicine.
This report argues that the legal, medical, and teaching professions provide a vital link between public service and the wider common good. Yet this understanding of civic purpose is in crisis, and the professions too often have come to be seen as self-serving interest groups. The conception of professionalism founded on the performance of duties has been eroded, with transactionality, narrowing specialisation, and the meeting of imposed targets coming to characterise practice. The resultant loss of trust has been detrimental to both practitioners and users of services.
We need to acknowledge the obligation of practitioners to serve the common good in order to return law, medicine, and teaching to their proper status as vocations. This entails calling practitioners to reconsider their sense of professional purpose, and allowing the rebuilding of relationships, in which the doctor, teacher, and lawyer knows and seeks to serve all the needs of their patient, student, or client. Through this restoration of trust, it will be possible to return responsibility to members of the professions.
This report reasserts virtue as the hallmark of the professions and their practitioners. The continuous nature of the practice of virtue at every stage of professional life must be grasped, embedding a consideration of practical wisdom and reflective practice in both training and professional life. In this way, the professions will once again fulfil their calling as vocations that serve the good of all.
Report co-author and ResPublica director Phillip Blond, said:
“Action is needed in the face of health service scandals such as the appalling lack of care exposed at the Mid Staffordshire NHS Trust in 2013, a negative attitude towards lawyers and an education system which sees around 40% of teachers leave the profession within five years.
“While state intervention is used to solve problems this can see money taken away from professions such as law and centralisation only serves to create a disconnected NHS. In teaching, a rule-driven regulatory system compounds the problems of low morale among classroom staff, thereby reducing levels of performance.”
Shadow Education Minister Baroness Jones said:
“Recent years have seen a disastrous erosion of trust in the teaching, medical, and legal professions. Despite the efforts of many practitioners, these professions have increasingly come to be seen as self-serving interest groups.
“ResPublica’s report rightly calls for teachers, lawyers, and medics to be reconnected with their vocation to serve the public good and also allowed to rely on the practical wisdom that they have accumulated along the way. The recommendations should be given serious consideration by all those concerned with restoring trust to our institutions and common life.
Schools face a real challenge in reconnecting with their communities as well as raising the status and quality of the teaching profession. The Report provides some inspiring and provocative ideas which begin to address these issues.”
Chief Executive of the General Medical Council, Niall Dickson:
‘The report is a useful contribution to an incredibly important debate and its message reflects many of the principles we are adopting in our work on medical professionalism. While clinical and technical skills remain absolutely essential, we recognise just how vital it is to foster professional skills which countless inquiries have shown are also vital if patients are to receive safe, effective and compassionate care.”
The Report’s co-author Professor Elena Antonacopoulou, of the University of Liverpool, further explains that professional politics and unwritten mandates of ‘the way we do things around here’ in the workplace often stand in the way of ordinary morality according to individual and social conscience. Professor Antonacopoulou said:
“These and other conditions provide a framework that simply does not work, and codes of ethical conduct do little to avert professional misconduct. They do not work to inspire motivate and engage professionals to perform professional practice with pride and confidence, dutifulness and conviction, aspiration and ambition, attentiveness and tenacity. They merely encourage and reward mediocrity and getting by with what is possible to do and still get away with it”.
She goes on to explain that “what is needed are modes of learning and changing otherwise referred to as ‘reflexive critique’ that promote not only exercising judgment in widening the repertoire of action, but also examining professional and personal life holistically thus, practising virtuousness through a code of chivalry and with altruism”.
A selection of quotes from the launch event:
Excellent @res_publica event on professions & #virtue. Opening the professional & public space will enable teachers to achieve even more
For any queries about the project, please contact Jenny Leigh at firstname.lastname@example.org.
This publication has kindly been supported by:
Key recommendations of the report include:
Key recommendations of the report include:
External suppliers should be allowed to compete to supply this wrap around care if the NHS can’t provide it.
Lawyers should be made to swear an oath making a public commitment to act ethically and for the common good.
A rewards system where doctors, teachers and lawyers who embody the ideals of their professions are lauded. These people would be ‘Ambassadors’ for excellent practice in their professions. The report says rather than creating more rules and regulations all three professions must move towards rewarding virtuous character in those exemplifying the best of their professions.
Other recommendations are:
For the Medical Profession:
’Stop the Line’: Implement a system whereby any health service employee can stop a process that harms the fundamental mission of a hospital.
Cross-disciplinary teams to oversee care: Regular meetings with all professionals concerned with patient care to ensure an integrated and holistic service is provided.
For the Teaching Profession:
’Local School Support Zones’: Establish a system where successful schools are linked to poorly performing schools to elevate standards.
University Schools: Develop partnerships between schools and local universities to create hubs of educational excellence.
For the Law Profession:
’Duty to mediate’: Report authors call on the Government to assess the benefits of primary legislation that could create a duty to mediate in every case.
Mandatory pro-bono work: All lawyers should be obliged to do pro-bono work to increase access to justice for the poorest in society. The pro-bono obligation should be set at 10% of all work done by solicitors and barristers. ResPublica says this would produce 26 million hours of free legal advice for the public every year in England and Wales.
Phillip is an internationally recognised political thinker and social and economic commentator. He bridges the gap between politics and practice, offering strategic consultation and policy formation to governments, businesses and organisations across the world. He founded ResPublica in 2009 and...
Elena Antonacopoulou is a Professor of Organizational Behaviour at University of Liverpool Management School. She previously held faculty positions at Warwick Business School, Manchester Business School and the University of Manchester Institute of Science and Technology (UMIST). She earned her...
Privacy & Cookies Policy
Necessary cookies are absolutely essential for the website to function properly. This category only includes cookies that ensures basic functionalities and security features of the website. These cookies do not store any personal information.
Any cookies that may not be particularly necessary for the website to function and is used specifically to collect user personal data via analytics, ads, other embedded contents are termed as non-necessary cookies. It is mandatory to procure user consent prior to running these cookies on your website.