Filter By

Responsible Recovery: Balancing economic and social priorities

Kate Green MP, Shadow Minister for Equalities, writes for the ResPublica fringe magazine

I take it as a given that economic performance and social justice go hand in hand. Social goals: equality, the eradication of poverty, building strong communities, enabling everyone to participate fully in society, and the right to respect and dignity, are most readily achieved through - and, I’d argue, prerequisites for - sustainable economic growth.

There’s plenty of evidence for this assertion, whether from the highly influential work of Richard Wilkinson and Kate Pickett, popularised in “The Spirit Level”, showing the superior performance of more equal societies against a whole set of social and economic indicators, or the recent findings from the International Labour Organisation and International Institute for Labour Studies that those countries that prioritised income transfers to poorer households have seen the fastest economic recovery.

So the argument isn’t about whether, but how to balance economic recovery and social goals. Sadly, nearly everything you can think of that’s being done by the present government goes in the opposite direction. The economy’s in recession, the highly respected IFS says child poverty’s set to rise. Disabled people are being singled out for welfare cuts, while public attitudes to disabled people harden, and disability hate crimes on the increase. The causes of last summer’s riots are undoubtedly complex, but the independent Riots, Communities and Victims panel’s findings are unequivocal:  many young people lack a sense of hope for the future in an age of record youth unemployment.

What could a different approach look like, and what might Labour do differently? Here are three suggestions, which have tackling poverty and inequality at their heart.

First, rethink fiscal policy by rebalancing the approach to tax and spending cuts. Analysis of the Chancellor’s budgets and spending reviews since June 2010 shows that, with the exception of the very richest 10%, the impact of the measures is highly regressive: the poorest take most pain. Yet, as the IMF itself has pointed out, putting money into the pockets of the poor is the most effective form of economic stimulus – they go out and spend.

The poorest families stand to lose over £20billion from tax credit and benefit cuts by 2015, as the Child Poverty Action Group has shown. CPAG suggests the “fiscal hindrance” effect on the economy could be a £32billion reduction in GDP as a result.

Tax cuts (including even that favourite of Liberal Democrats, cutting tax rates at the bottom) favour the better off. A more progressive tax system alongside not slashing welfare benefits should be the priority – not only to bring much-needed funds into the economy, and not only because cutting poverty doesn’t just help the immediate recovery but also brings long-term savings to the Exchequer (research by the Joseph Rowntree Foundation has suggested that the cost of child poverty to the public purse could be in the region of £25billion a year), but as a matter of simple fairness.

Second, invest in infrastructure spending that simultaneously supports economic growth and promotes greater equality. That means investment in good quality childcare (which brings the greatest developmental benefits to the most disadvantaged children, and supports women’s employment); investment in more affordable housing to create jobs and homes, and help build stable communities (the government’s policies are proving woefully inadequate, with the most recent figures showing a 24% fall in the number of new homes started compared with the same period last year); and investment in education. Following the hike in university fees to £9,000, we’ve seen a 7.7% fall in the number of applicants for university places compared with the equivalent point last year – something that makes no sense when our global competitive position depends on a highly skilled workforce.

Third, tackle the discrimination and disadvantage in the labour market that means that women, disabled people, those from certain BME backgrounds, older and younger workers, experience significant under or unemployment. There’s a whole range of policy solutions that could be developed, from offering incentives to employers who take on a young or disabled worker, to anonymising applications processes to deal with employer discrimination, to mandatory pay audits. The government has only a one-club approach to maximising labour market participation – a Work Programme that isn’t actually working.  Rather than focussing exclusively on supply side measures, we need policies that dismantle barriers that stop people working and create more opportunity for people to work -  not least, of course, including the creation of jobs. 

All this might seem too simplistic or obvious an approach, but what we need are policies that are effective. Policies that maximise social and economic participation not only increase economic performance, they deliver stronger communities, improve social justice, and promote equality for all. Those are the goals that must remain at the front and centre of public policy.

This article has been published in the ResPublica Fringe magazine, a collection of articles and essays from our party conference partners.

Kate Green MP will be speaking at ‘Responsible recovery: Balancing economic and social priorities’, a ResPublica public fringe event at Labour Party conference: Wednesday 3rd October, 4.00pm – 5.15pm, Manchester Town Hall.




Comments on: Responsible Recovery: Balancing economic and social priorities

Join the discussion Have opinions on this matter? Why not get involved and comment on this below.

Become a Member Joining ResPublica give you an exclusive amount of features. Gain early access to ResPublica events, contribute to topics and much more.

Detailed Summary

Date Published
03 October 2012

Issue(s)
New Economies, Innovative Markets

About The Authors

Kate Green MP

Kate Green was elected MP for Stretford and Urmston in May 2010. She is currently shadow spokesperson for Women and E...