Norman Lamb MP, former Minister for Employment Relations, Consumer and Postal Affairs and new Minister of State for Care Services, calls for greater employee-ownership
It is no secret that I am a
passionate advocate of greater employee-ownership. I was thrilled when, at the
beginning of this year, Nick Clegg launched a government push to promote
mutuals and I am delighted now to be the minister charged with delivering on
this ambition. I am also proud that Liberal Democrats will be debating the
issue at this year’s Autumn Conference.
Employee ownership is not just a
niche issue. As the title of this fringe event suggests, it has a role to play
in achieving this Government’s key goal of long-term, sustainable and balanced
growth.
Research by the Cass Business School
has shown that employee-owned businesses are just as profitable as traditional
companies and that their performance is more stable over the business cycle.
Interestingly, during the recession they proved to be more resilient than
traditional companies. They consistently recruited more staff, and get more out
of them: productivity tends to be better at companies with an element of
employee-ownership. Other evidence shows that rewards are distributed more
evenly within an employee-owned business, with a smaller gap between the top
and the average worker’s pay.
The Liberal Democrats, and the
Liberals before them, have long been standard-bearers for this agenda. John
Stuart Mill argued that, “the efficiency and economy of production on a large
scale, may be obtained without dividing the producers into two parties with
hostile interests and feelings,” and predicted that, “the relation of masters
and work-people will be gradually superseded by partnership.” Jo Grimond,
inspired by a visit to the Mondragon
co-operative in Spain, founded the organisation that developed into today’s
Employee Ownership Association. At this year’s Liberal Democrat conference
delegates will be debating and voting on the party’s policy in this area, which
has been reviewed by a party working group over the last year.
In Government, we have already made
significant progress in this area. We plan to give employees a stake in Royal
Mail and have ambitious plans to establish a mutually owned Post office, giving
sub-postmasters and employees a stake in the business and also giving consumers
a voice. Graeme Nuttall, an expert in the field, was appointed the government’s
independent advisor on employee ownership back in February and spent the
intervening months investigating the barriers to greater employee ownership. He
split these barriers into three broad areas: a lack of awareness of the
concept; a lack of resources available to support it; and a complicated – or
seemingly complicated – legal, tax and regulatory framework.
Graeme’s report is now available
online, and was presented at a summit hosted by the Deputy Prime Minister
shortly before the summer recess. Groups from the sector were in attendance, as
were major law and accountancy firms, professional bodies, business advisors,
academics, banks and policymakers whose support and expertise will be needed if
we really are to drive employee ownership from the fringes into the mainstream
of the British economy.
Graeme laid down a challenge to
Government: to maintain the focus and the momentum on this issue and to
“translate its support into concrete changes”. I hope he will not be
disappointed when the Government’s response is published in the autumn. Indeed,
we have already announced that an independent, expert Institute for Employee
Ownership will be established; launched a call for evidence on how a Right to
Request employee ownership could work in practice; and started working on new
off-the-shelf ‘DIY packs’ for companies looking to adopt an employee-owned
business model. The publication of the Government’s response to the Nuttall
report will be another important step forward. However, there is much still to
do and I am utterly determined to make this happen. We have a vital opportunity
in Government to make real progress. All three main parties are broadly
supportive of this agenda, and there are knowledgeable, vocal champions of
employee ownership in the Conservative and Labour parties as well as in the
Liberal Democrats.
It is an idea whose time has come,
and one that speaks to many of our current concerns. Whether it is about
securing balanced, sustainable growth; addressing the disparity of pay between
the boardroom and the shop floor; moving beyond the greed and short-term
thinking which led to the financial crisis; or giving people a greater voice in
the workplace, employee ownership and the principles which underpin it has
something new and something very valuable to offer.
This article has been published in the ResPublica Fringe magazine, a collection of articles and essays from our party conference partners.
Norman Lamb MP will be speaking at
‘Choice in social care: Making care personal’, a ResPublica public fringe event
co-hosted with Home Instead and Keyring at Liberal Democrat Party conference:
Tuesday 25th September, 12.30pm – 1.45pm, Holiday Inn Brighton.
ResPublica will also be hosting ‘Employee
Ownership: Driving co-operation, achieving long-term sustainability’, on the
same day, 6.15pm – 7.45pm, with the new Minister for Employment Relations, Jo
Swinson MP.